Few episodes in the history of medicine illustrate the gap between scientific evidence and clinical practice more starkly than conversion therapy. The practice’s foundational claims were being systematically refuted for decades before legislation began to restrict it, and the harm being done to the people subjected to it was documented long before most institutions acted on that documentation. Conversion Truth for Families offers an educational account of that history for parents and caregivers, sourced throughout primary research and federal agency guidance.
The practice was born inside academic psychiatry. Richard von Krafft-Ebing’s 1886 publication Psychopathia Sexualis classified same-sex attraction as pathological and gave the idea of clinical intervention its foundational authority. Freud’s role in this history is more nuanced than popular accounts suggest. In a 1935 letter to an American mother, he wrote that homosexuality was nothing to be ashamed of. His American successors were less ambivalent. Sandor Rado in 1940 argued that heterosexuality was the only biologically sound orientation. Irving Bieber and colleagues in 1962 built on that argument to claim a 27% conversion rate from a study later found to be methodologically unsound and reliant on outcomes that could not be independently verified.
Behavioral psychology added methods that made the pathology framing actionable in more immediate and damaging ways. Chemical aversion therapy. Electrical aversion therapy. In 1952, Alan Turing — a mathematician, wartime codebreaker, computing pioneer — was subjected to chemical castration as a court-ordered alternative to imprisonment. He died in 1954. These were not outlier experiments conducted without institutional backing. They recognized clinical procedures.
The positive-outcomes literature that underpinned conversion practice was consistently weak on examination. Douglas Haldeman’s 1994 systematic review in the Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology identified recurring problems: self-selected samples, no control groups; outcomes measured in behavioral terms rather than changes in underlying attraction. Masters and Johnson’s 1979 work, which claimed a 71.6% success rate, was investigated by The Atlantic in 2012. Reporters found no contemporaneous patient records to verify those claimed outcomes. The study is no longer cited as credible by any major medical organization.
The APA’s December 1973 vote to remove homosexuality from the DSM was the central institutional event in conversion therapy’s clinical history, made possible in significant part by Dr. Evelyn Hooker’s 1957 research showing that trained clinicians could not reliably distinguish gay from heterosexual men’s psychological profiles. The DSM-III in 1980 introduced ego-dystonic homosexuality, however, preserving a clinical pathway for orientation-change treatment until 1987. The Williams Institute estimated in 2019 that approximately 698,000 LGBTQIA+ adults in the United States had been subjected to conversion therapy at some point in their lives, with about 350,000 having experienced it as minors.
Conversion Truth for Families documents the harm research in detail. The APA’s 2009 Task Force reviewed 83 peer-reviewed studies and found no credible evidence of lasting orientation change, while documenting consistent links to depression, anxiety, and suicidal ideation. A 2020 JAMA Psychiatry study found that recalled conversion exposure was associated with elevated psychological distress and lifetime suicide attempts among transgender adults. Research from the Family Acceptance Project found that youth subjected to both parental and clinical conversion efforts attempted suicide at a rate of 63%, compared to 22% among peers without such exposure. SAMHSA’s 2023 report concluded that SOGI change efforts in children and adolescents are harmful and should never be provided.
Robert Spitzer’s story is particularly significant. His 2003 study claimed some individuals could achieve meaningful orientation change. He retracted those conclusions in 2012 and apologized to individuals who had spent years in what he described as useless attempts to change.
Conversion Truth for Families also documents the rebranding problem — the use of new terminology such as “sexual attraction fluidity exploration in therapy” or “reintegrative therapy” for functionally similar interventions. SAMHSA’s 2023 report names these variants. The APA’s 2021 resolution confirmed that voluntariness does not address questions about evidence base or documented risk. California enacted the first minor-focused ban in 2012. More than 23 states and the District of Columbia had followed by early 2026. Canada criminalized the practice nationally in 2021. The World Health Organization called for global elimination in 2023.





